Moffat was an excellent writer of individual episodes who in my opinion was not nearly as good as a showrunner. Perhaps Chibnall will turn out to be a so-so writer of individual episodes who will shine when put in charge. Time (Lords) will tell.
This is my thought, as well.
I remember when RTD left and people were pleased to have someone new at the helm, particularly Moffat who at the time was great with writing individual episodes, most of which were considered fan favorites. But he then proved he wasn't as competent of a showrunner as he was with his stand-alone episodes, leading many people tired at his continued lazy arc writing and "twist" antics. I know that Chibnall hasn't had a great track record with his writing of DW or Torchwood in the past, but some have said he has improved with Broadchurch. So, we'll just have to wait and see how he handles things.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
regna
(no subject)
Date: 2016-01-23 05:45 am (UTC)This is my thought, as well.
I remember when RTD left and people were pleased to have someone new at the helm, particularly Moffat who at the time was great with writing individual episodes, most of which were considered fan favorites. But he then proved he wasn't as competent of a showrunner as he was with his stand-alone episodes, leading many people tired at his continued lazy arc writing and "twist" antics. I know that Chibnall hasn't had a great track record with his writing of DW or Torchwood in the past, but some have said he has improved with Broadchurch. So, we'll just have to wait and see how he handles things.